The word "championship" is too grandiose for Dail to even fathom in September. A team full of newcomers will need to break the habits of park-style, pick-up basketball before they can start to string together wins.
"We've got to start from the beginning, we've got to get back to teaching basic basketball," Dail said. "With the new players, we have the talent, but we don't have the IQ. So that's something we have to key in on right now. We've got to make them mesh with the players who are returning."
If there's anything comforting about what's been a rough 0-8 start to their season, it's that Dail isn't totally alone on this journey as a first time CUNY coach. The College of Staten Island, which bested CCNY's Beavers in the championship game just months ago, is also working with a new, young head coach, T.J. Tibbs, who also formerly played at his school. CSI's former coach, Tony Petosa, who has six CUNY championships under his belt, including last year's win, resigned after 27 years in the program, citing his reason for leaving as "fifty percent personal and fifty percent basketball," and a decision that was "six years in the making." In a press release issued by the college after his resignation, Petosa mentioned that he found himself doing "less and less teaching" and spending more time handling "frustrating" administrative issues, including, but not limited to, playing guidance counselor and situating his players into classes.
The two teams met again for a CUNY championship rematch on Saturday, December 9th, this time across the Verrazano bridge. But it was hardly as competitive as March's heated game. While both teams have undergone complete personnel makeovers, the Dolphins had retained enough of their roster from last year to rout CCNY 83-47.
Tibbs, however, shared a moment with Dail before the game, when the two met--as their respective teams were warming up--to congratulate each other. These are two young men, likely some of the youngest in all of the NCAA, who got unexpected gigs coaching their alma maters' basketball teams. And although a fierce rivalry budded between the two teams just a season ago, Tibbs says now that it's a fresh slate; there aren't going to be any hard feelings between the two rookie coaches over last year's competition. In fact, he admires Dail as an opponent in a still-competitive CUNY league. Even after a blow-out win.
"Both of us are coming in and trying to do new things," Tibbs says. "I think we both know last year was last year. I know he wanted to win [Saturday's] game as much as I wanted to win that game. I wouldn't expect anything less of him being the competitor that he was as a player."
Tibbs, 29, graduated CSI in 2013, just as Dail completed his CCNY career in 2013. But Tibbs went straight for the coaching circuit upon graduating, first serving as director of basketball operations at the New Jersey Institute for Technology for a year before returning to the CUNY league in 2014 to become an assistant coach at Baruch. With coaching experience under his belt, his resume topples Dail's, but Tibbs understands what Dail is going through.
"In your first year as a head coach, it's really important that you have a lot of support," Tibbs says. "You can't have any success without support from your administration. I think Coach Dail is going to do a great job over there. They definitely did a fine job bringing him in."